You Chose Her, So I Choose Myself
Chapter 8
During the drive, Nathaniel kept one arm wrapped around me, holding me close as he tried to reassure me.
“There's no reason to be frightened anymore,” he murmured. “I'm with you this time, and I won't let anything happen to you.”
I said nothing, choosing instead to watch the scenery pass beyond the car window.
When we arrived, the house looked exactly as I remembered it, bright and welcoming on the surface, as though nothing terrible had ever happened within its walls.
I barely touched my food once we sat down for dinner.
My mother continued fussing over Isabelle, my adopted sister, treating her as though she were the most precious person in the room, while my father readily followed her lead.
Although Nathaniel was seated beside me, his attention was never entirely on me. His eyes kept wandering toward Isabelle, and he noticed every little thing she did.
Whenever she dropped her fork, he immediately replaced it. When her glass was empty, he got up to refill it, and whenever food touched the corner of her mouth, he instinctively reached for a napkin.
His actions came so naturally, as though looking after her had always been his responsibility.
Isabelle giggled. “All right, you two, stop pampering me so much. My sister has only just come home, and I should at least behave myself.”
My mother glanced in my direction and sighed. “She hardly eats whenever she visits. She's always been that way.”
My father shook his head disapprovingly. “She's been difficult since she was little. Nothing ever seems to please her.”
Something inside me finally snapped.
I pushed my chair back and stood up.
“The reason I barely eat here is because I'm allergic to the food you prepare,” I said calmly. “You always make everything according to Isabelle's preferences, anyway.”
The entire table fell silent.
I looked at my parents before turning toward Nathaniel, keeping my voice steady.
“All I ever wanted was to live peacefully. Was that really asking too much?”
Nobody answered.
With that, I turned and walked away.
Isabelle hurried after me and caught my arm.
“Please don't be upset, Sister. Mom and Dad didn't mean to hurt you…”
I was about to pull away when a sudden shout interrupted us.
“Watch out! Get out of the way!”
I turned just in time to see a bulldog running straight toward us after breaking free from its leash.
Before I could react, my parents and Nathaniel rushed toward Isabelle, immediately surrounding her to shield her from the approaching animal.
“Belle!”
They pulled her behind them, leaving me completely exposed.
I barely managed to move aside before the dog lunged at me.
A sharp pain ripped through my arm as its jaws clamped down on my skin. I fell backward, my vision blurring as the unbearable sting spread through my injured arm.
Through my fading vision, I could still see my parents frantically checking Isabelle for injuries, examining her face and arms while asking if she was all right.
Nathaniel had already pulled her into his embrace.
“It's okay, Belle. You're safe. I've got you.”
His voice was gentle and reassuring, the same voice that had once made me feel protected.
But nobody came to check on me.
Not even once.
Blood trickled down my arm, yet I could only stare at them in disbelief.
So this was what I had become to them.
Someone they couldn't even be bothered to look back for.
…
When I regained consciousness, I found myself in another hospital room, my injured arm wrapped in bandages and throbbing beneath them.
Outside, I could hear my parents speaking with the doctor.
“How's the baby doing?” my mother asked anxiously. “Everything is fine, right? There weren't any complications?”
My fingers tightened around the blanket.
I sat up, reached for the glass of water beside me, and hurled it toward the floor.
CRASH!
The sound of breaking glass finally caught their attention.
“I'm perfectly fine,” I said coldly. “And so is the baby.”
The doctor glanced between us, looking rather uncomfortable. I gave her a warning look, silently reminding her not to reveal that I wasn't actually pregnant. Understanding my signal, she nodded before quickly leaving the room.
My mother finally breathed a sigh of relief, although her expression soon turned disapproving.
“She didn't even think to protect herself,” she complained. “Thank goodness the baby wasn't harmed. She's already so far along. What would we have done if something had happened?”
I stared at her in silence.
So that was all I was worth to them now: a vessel carrying a child.
They were only concerned because losing the baby would mean Isabelle might lose her supposed treatment opportunity, along with the illness they had all been fooled into believing she had.
I nearly told them the truth.
Isabelle was never sick. Not even once.
But I swallowed my words and said nothing, allowing them to remain trapped in their own lies.
Nathaniel approached and sat beside my bed.
“Serena,” he said gently. “I thought you were in danger, so I rushed to protect you. I never meant to leave you behind.”
“It's all right,” I interrupted. “I understand.”
I had no desire to listen to another one of his excuses. They were always the same, always coming too late and never making anything right.
During the following days, my family remained at the hospital with me, although none of them seemed genuinely present.
My mother was constantly checking her phone for news about Isabelle, while my father repeatedly found reasons to step outside and call her.
Nathaniel stayed beside my bed, but his attention kept wandering elsewhere, as though his thoughts were always with someone else.
I watched them quietly, knowing that I wouldn't have to endure this much longer.
Soon, everything would be over.
…
On the day I was scheduled to leave the hospital, I received a phone call.
“Your enrollment at Sunvale Academy has been confirmed,” the person on the other end informed me. “You may leave whenever you're ready.”
I tightened my grip on the phone before answering.
“I'll leave tomorrow.”
After ending the call, I put my phone down and tried not to think twice about my decision.
A short while later, Nathaniel entered the room.
“Who were you talking to?” he asked, looking at me suspiciously.
“Just someone,” I replied without meeting his eyes.
He studied me briefly, seemingly trying to figure out what I was hiding, before letting out a quiet sigh.
“My birthday banquet is tomorrow,” he announced. “Isabelle has already arranged everything, and I want you to come with me.”
I offered no response, but he seemed content to interpret my silence as agreement.
…
The following morning, I sat on the edge of the bed with one hand resting lightly over my stomach.
“I don't think I feel well,” I told him when he approached.
Nathaniel immediately frowned. “What's wrong? Are you experiencing pain? Is something happening to the baby?”
“He's been kicking quite hard,” I replied, lowering my eyes. “You should go ahead without me. It's your special day, after all. I've already prepared your present, and I'll have it delivered later.”
He hesitated, studying my expression as though he suspected something, but I remained composed.
After a moment, he finally sighed.
“Are you certain you'll be all right by yourself?”
“It's nothing serious. I'll be fine, so don't worry.”
He gently brushed my cheek with his hand.
“Call me immediately if you feel any worse. Don't hesitate, understand?”
“I will.”
He nodded and stepped away.
“I'll try to come home early after the banquet. Wait for me.”
Then he finally left.
Once the door closed, I remained where I was for a moment, listening until I was certain he was gone.
Only then did I get up.
I opened the drawer and took out the three boxes I had prepared well in advance.
The first was addressed to Nathaniel. Inside was a signed divorce agreement, along with everything he had never bothered to ask about but deserved to know.
The second was for my parents. There was no letter, only the documents severing every remaining tie between us.
The third box was heavier than the others.
It was meant for everyone.
Inside was a USB drive containing Isabelle's private conversations, her fabricated illness, and all the lies she had carefully woven into the story my family believed. It also contained footage revealing where Nathaniel's attention had truly been all along.
After carefully wrapping the box, I contacted a delivery service.
When the courier arrived, I handed it to him.
“Please deliver this to the birthday banquet tonight, and make sure it's opened in front of everyone.”
He nodded without asking any questions and left with the package.
I stood quietly for a moment, looking at the empty doorway before reaching for my luggage.
Then I walked out of the house, never once turning back.