You Chose Her, So I Choose Myself
Chapter 2
The memories kept rushing back, one painful recollection after another, until I felt as though I was being consumed by everything I had tried so hard to forget.
My mother nearly died when she gave birth to me. My parents had reminded me of that countless times, making me feel as though I had somehow caused her suffering simply by being born. She had never been particularly affectionate toward me, and I could always see the resentment in her eyes whenever she looked my way.
My father wasn't any different. He loved my mother so deeply that he seemed to have developed the same resentment toward me.
Everything changed when they adopted Isabelle.
From then on, she became the center of our family, and everyone seemed eager to make her happy.
I remembered her school party, where my parents arrived early in their finest clothes, smiling proudly as they accompanied her around the venue and took countless pictures together.
My own school event happened that same week. I waited outside the gate until evening, hoping they would eventually show up, but neither of them came.
I kept telling myself they must have been occupied with something important, even though deep down, I knew they had simply forgotten about me.
There was also the time Isabelle fell and injured her knee. Although it was only a minor scrape, my parents immediately rushed to her side, spending the entire night comforting her and calling doctors to make sure she was alright.
That same week, our driver forgot to pick me up from school.
I stayed by the gate until the sun went down, watching the other students leave one after another. Eventually, even the guards began closing the school entrance, leaving me with no choice but to walk home despite not knowing the way.
That was when I noticed a man following me.
His footsteps grew closer, and fear immediately took hold of me. I ran as fast as I could, crying and struggling to breathe, terrified that he would catch up with me.
Fortunately, one of my teachers spotted me along the road. She pulled over, helped me into her car, and personally drove me home.
When we arrived, I could hear laughter coming from inside the house. My family was enjoying their evening together, completely unaware that I had been left alone outside for hours.
I should have realized then that I could never expect them to come looking for me.
For a long time, I thought that was all life had in store for me until the Cumberland banquet came along.
I hadn't wanted to attend, knowing I would feel out of place among the wealthy and influential guests. Isabelle made things worse when she deliberately pushed me into the swimming pool.
The freezing water soaked my dress, leaving me struggling to climb out as the surrounding guests burst into laughter.
"Well, look who's making a fool of herself again," Isabelle remarked with a sweet smile. "You really are unwanted, Serena. Even your own parents would rather have nothing to do with you."
I stood there, drenched and humiliated, while everyone continued laughing.
Then Nathaniel appeared.
He immediately removed his suit jacket and placed it around my shoulders before turning toward the crowd.
"Is there something amusing about what happened? If anyone still wants to laugh, I'd suggest having the courage to do it in front of me."
His words were enough to silence everyone.
For the first time, someone had stood up for me without hesitation. That was the moment I began falling for him, especially when he pursued me afterward and made me feel that I was someone worth loving.
After our wedding, he gave me everything I could have wanted. He bought beautiful houses, showered me with attention, and always seemed reluctant to spend time away from me.
However, things were different when we were alone at night.
Even when I became uncomfortable and asked him to slow down, he would hold me more firmly and continue without paying much attention to my pleas.
I told myself that perhaps this was simply another side of being loved. I believed he wanted me as much as I wanted him, never imagining that his intentions were entirely different.
Three years ago, Isabelle suddenly developed what my parents described as a rare blood disorder. According to the doctors, she needed a stem cell transplant from someone with an almost perfect genetic match.
I remembered sitting in the hospital while the physicians discussed her treatment.
"One possibility is for Miss Serena Whitmore to have a child. There's a chance the baby could be a suitable genetic match and provide the fetal stem cells Isabelle needs."
At the time, I hadn't given their suggestion much thought.
But now, everything made sense.
Was that when Nathaniel first decided to pursue me? Had he deliberately entered my life because he needed a child who could save Isabelle?
Were all his affectionate gestures, his promises, and even his efforts to get me pregnant nothing more than a carefully planned arrangement?
I felt sick just thinking about it.
While I was still trying to make sense of everything, I heard Isabelle talking on the phone outside my hospital room.
"There's really nothing to worry about. I'm perfectly healthy, and the whole illness was fabricated," she said, laughing. "I only pretended to need fetal stem cells because I wanted to see Serena suffer. It was amusing watching everyone run around for my sake."
My chest tightened as I listened.
"And Nathaniel still believes I'm the woman he met that evening. He has no idea that the girl playing the piano in the garden was actually Serena. Isn't that hilarious?"
My fingers turned cold.
What did she mean?
"I'm certainly not going to let her have him," Isabelle continued, her voice suddenly losing its playful tone. "Nathaniel belongs to me, and I won't allow anyone, especially Serena, to take him away."
The call ended, but I remained frozen in place.
Nathaniel had mistaken me for Isabelle, and because of that misunderstanding, I had become nothing more than a woman he could use to get what he wanted.
I glanced at my phone and realized I had accidentally recorded their entire conversation. At least I now had evidence of Isabelle's confession.
Somehow, I managed to make my way to the doctor's office, where I immediately told him what I wanted.
"I want to terminate my pregnancy."
The doctor looked startled. "Mrs. Cumberland, you're already eight months pregnant. This is a serious decision, and I strongly advise you to reconsider. Are you absolutely certain?"
"Yes. I've already made up my mind."
He hesitated before explaining, "Mr. Cumberland has given specific instructions regarding this pregnancy. We cannot proceed without his authorization, so he will need to sign the consent form."
I wasn't surprised. Even something concerning my own body had to be approved by Nathaniel.
"Then give me the form."
My hands trembled as I accepted the document before turning toward the door.
...
The moment I stepped outside, I nearly bumped into Nathaniel.
He was still wearing his immaculate suit, although his expression suggested that he had been searching for me in a hurry. As soon as he saw me, he pulled me into his arms.
"Where have you been, Serena? I've been worried sick since you disappeared. You should have told me before leaving. What if something had happened to you?"
His familiar tenderness would once have been enough to make me feel safe, but now it only reminded me of his betrayal.
I looked up at him. "Would it really bother you if something happened to me?"
He frowned before gently touching my cheek.
"Of course it would. You're the most important person in my life, and you're carrying our baby. How could I possibly not worry about you?"
Our baby.
I tightened my grip on the consent form, forcing myself to remain calm before handing it to him.
"The doctor needs your signature for a checkup."
He initially accepted it without question, but his eyes soon settled on the document.
"What kind of examination requires my signature?"
My heart began racing, and I quickly covered the lower portion of the paper.
"It's just a routine screening for women in the final weeks of pregnancy. The doctor said it's necessary."
He seemed about to question me further when his phone suddenly vibrated.
A message from Isabelle appeared on the screen.
[Nathaniel, I'm feeling dizzy...]
I watched his expression change as his attention immediately shifted to her.
Without another word, he hurriedly signed the document and handed it back to me.