My Mafia Fiancé Sent Me to Room 1206. I Changed Grooms

Chapter 3

5,358 words

Once I thought about it, I couldn’t remember the last time Seth and I had gone out without Leonora turning up. At the Vances’ supper club, she’d slide into the booth before the waiter brought the wine. Anywhere else, Seth would say she was nearby and ask if I minded. Of course I didn’t. She was my best friend.

I went back to the apartment I shared with Seth, my phone still open to the investigator’s screenshot.

The doorman at Seth’s building on the Upper East Side took one look at me and reached for the house phone. I waved him off. The brass key Seth had given me still turned in the lock. I shoved the door open.

Leonora was on the couch with one leg across Seth’s lap. His hand was under her blouse. When he saw me, he pulled it free and frowned.

“You don’t know how to knock?”

I’d lived there long enough to know which floorboard creaked on the way to the kitchen. He was asking me to knock.

Leonora scrambled up, doing up her blouse with shaking fingers. Then she saw my face.

“Clara. Who hit you?”

My cheek had burned since I caught it on the chair at the clinic. I hadn’t looked in a mirror. From the way she stared, I figured it had started to bruise.

“Tell me who did it,” she said, coming toward me. “I’ll go down there myself and…”

“Drop it, Leonora.”

I shoved her. She caught her heel on the edge of the rug and went down.

Seth was off the couch before she could get up. He took her elbow, pulled her to her feet, and stepped in front of her.

“What the hell is wrong with you? She asked if you were hurt.”

“Clara, please,” Leonora said from behind him. Her eyes were already filling. “Just tell me what happened. Whoever did this, I’ll make them pay.”

I tossed my phone onto the couch beside her. It landed screen up.

“Go on,” I said. “Read the name at the top.”

She bent just far enough to see it. Her hands dropped to her sides.

“I didn’t put it in that chat,” she said. “Clara, you know I’d never do that to you.”

She came toward me crying, reaching for my arm the way she used to when I got quiet in a crowded room. I slapped her before she could touch me.

“I told you things I couldn’t tell anybody else. I took you to those appointments and sat up with you afterward. I never once pushed you to tell me his name.” My voice cracked. “And all that time it was Seth. Now your name’s on the message that sent that video around again.”

“She doesn’t owe you for every favor you ever did her,” Seth said. “And a screenshot could come from anywhere. You really think that proves something?”

He looked at Leonora’s cheek and his jaw tightened.

“She baked your birthday cake in a dorm kitchen with one working burner. Remember that? When you got sick, she practically carried you to student health. She spent nights going after people who talked about you online. And this is what she gets?”

I remembered the cake. She’d brought it to my room in the pan because she couldn’t get it out without breaking it. I’d eaten the first piece with a spoon while she sat cross-legged on my bed.

Seth saw me hesitate.

“Anyway,” he said, “you handed them the condom yourself. I saw the video, Clara. You went along with it.”

The room went so quiet I could hear the ice settling in his glass.

At the precinct, I’d told Seth why I’d done that before I managed to tell the detective. He’d sat there with my coat across his knees and told me to take my time. Now he was using the hardest thing I’d ever said out loud to win an argument.

My teeth started to chatter. I pressed my lips together, but I couldn’t make it stop.

“Seth,” Leonora said. “How dare you?”

She shoved past him and put her arms around me.

“I’m defending you,” he said. “She hit you. Why are you taking her side?”

“Clara, listen to me.” Leonora held on tighter. “You were scared. You were trying to survive. Those men did that to you. It was their fault.”

I looked past her at my phone on the couch. The screen had gone dark.

“Say something,” she whispered. When I didn’t, she caught Seth by the sleeve and pulled him closer. “She’ll listen to you. Please. Say something to her.”

Seth got a good look at my face. His mouth opened. For a second, I thought he might actually say he was sorry.

He reached for me. I slapped his hand away.

“I don’t want to see either of you,” I said. “Get out.”

Seth let his hand drop. The look on his face changed.

“Take a look around, Clara. This is my apartment. If you want somebody to leave, it’ll be you.”

My shoes were under the hall bench. A stack of wedding invitations sat on the console where I’d left them. The apartment belonged to Seth, and the doorman would take my key the second he asked. I knew how quickly a place could stop being home. The Hensons had taught me that.

I started laughing. By the time I could speak, tears were running down my face.

“Fine,” I said. “You’ll never have to ask me to knock again.”

I picked up my phone and left the key on top of the invitations.

Outside, I walked until the doormen stopped looking familiar. My thumb went to Leonora’s name out of habit. She was the person I would’ve called if Seth had put me out. If Leonora had hurt me, I would’ve called Seth.

By Saturday, I was supposed to be in Harbor City, marrying into the Ashford family. Right then, I couldn’t think of one door in New York I wanted to knock on.

I put my phone in my pocket and kept walking.