My Mafia Fiancé Sent Me to Room 1206. I Changed Grooms

Chapter 1

6,397 words

A week before I was supposed to marry the heir to one of New York’s oldest Mafia families, a stranger asked what I’d do if my best friend had been sleeping with him for years.

For three years, I’d run an anonymous advice page under the name Dr. Henson. By day, I saw patients through a clinic, mostly over video. After hours, I answered questions from readers on the page. My fiancé’s father wanted it down before the wedding. He didn’t want reporters digging through my old posts once my name went in the papers.

I posted a goodbye and opened the account settings. Just as I was about to hit Deactivate, a message came in from a new follower with a blank profile.

Dr. Henson, what if your best friend had been sleeping with your fiancé for years and you found out a week before the wedding? Could you live with that?

I should’ve asked who was writing. Instead, I typed the first thing that came to mind.

My best friend would never sleep with my fiancé.

I almost laughed when I hit Send. Leonora Fox and I had known each other since we were girls, back when our fathers sent us to the far end of the table at Sunday dinner. I knew how she took her coffee after a sleepless night. I knew she’d been pregnant ten times and had never brought a baby home. I’d driven her home from the hospital more than once. She’d never told me the name of the man she kept going back to.

Whoever he was, she was still taking his calls.

I went back to the settings. My thumb was over the button when my phone buzzed again.

This time it was Seth, my fiancé.

Babe.

The typing bubble disappeared. Then it came back.

What if I told you I’ve been sleeping with your best friend?

……

Seth sent the address before I could answer.

The Marlowe. Room 1206.

The Vances owned the Marlowe. Seth’s father kept the top floor for family and for guests who needed privacy. I’d been there often enough to know the doorman by name.

I don’t remember how I got downstairs or how I found a cab. I remember giving the driver the hotel name and spending the whole ride waiting for Seth to text again.

Come on, babe. I’m kidding.

By the time we pulled up, I could almost hear him saying it.

The doorman stepped aside without a word. Upstairs, the door to 1206 was ajar. Seth had left it that way for me.

I pushed it open.

He was in bed with Leonora Fox. She had her cheek against his bare shoulder. When she saw me, she sat up and pulled the sheet to her chest.

Seth stayed where he was. He looked more annoyed than surprised.

“Jesus, babe. Did I really have to give you a room number before you’d believe me?”

My eyes burned. I’d spent the cab ride thinking of all the things I’d say if it turned out to be true. In the room, I could only get one word out.

“Why?”

“You know me, Clara. I have needs.” He said it as casually as if he were explaining why he’d ordered room service. “Ever since what happened to you, you can barely stand to have me touch you. With Leonora, I don’t have to stop every five seconds to ask if she’s okay.”

Leonora looked down at the sheet bunched in her hands.

“We don’t even use protection,” he went on. “If she gets pregnant again, she’ll take care of it. She always does.”

“Enough.”

I crossed the room and slapped him. His head turned with it. For the first time since I’d walked in, he looked surprised.

“You’re a goddamn animal, Seth.”

I turned to Leonora. She was still holding the sheet against her chest. I’d held her coat and her handbag while she cried in a hospital bathroom. I’d sat beside her afterward, waiting for a man she swore would come this time.

“I treated you like family. You were supposed to stand beside me next Saturday. Were you really going to let me walk down that aisle without telling me?”

She scrambled off the bed, caught a foot in the sheet, and dropped to her knees in front of me.

“Clara, I’m sorry. It was me. I went after him. I knew what I was doing, and I did it anyway.” Her voice cracked. “I’ll go. I won’t see him again.”

“She’s staying.”

Seth took her by the arm and helped her up. Then he looked at me as though I’d made some unreasonable demand.

“She never asked me to break off the engagement. Never asked for a ring or even for me to tell her I cared about her. She was willing to keep quiet so you could have the wedding you wanted. And now you want to run her off?”

I hadn’t asked Leonora to go anywhere. I’d barely had time to ask her why.

“And when the Hensons found out you weren’t theirs,” he went on, “who stuck around? You remember what people said about you. Leonora was the one who came to your door when everyone else was passing that video around.”

He put a hand on her shoulder. She leaned into it.

“You’d be dead without us, Clara. We’re getting married in seven days, same as we planned. I told you I’d take care of you. I keep my word.”

The tears came before I could turn my face away. I stood there looking at the two people I’d once trusted with things I’d never told anyone else.

I was seventeen when the woman I called Mom got sick. She needed blood, and I went to the hospital to see if I could donate. The screening turned up a blood type the family hadn’t expected. The Hensons insisted on a DNA test. When the results came back, I found out I wasn’t their daughter.

The men I’d grown up calling my father’s had driven me to school and waited outside my piano lessons. One of them put my suitcase on the front step the night the results came in. By midnight, word was already out. Men who’d spent years keeping their distance from a Henson cornered me in an alley. I’d spent years learning how to talk about what they did to me. Seth had just used it to explain why he’d slept with my best friend.

The video first made the rounds on campus during my sophomore year. My roommates stopped talking when I came into the room. One of my professors asked, in front of the class, which last name I wanted him to use.

Leonora lived next door. We’d barely spoken since the Hensons threw me out. She knocked the night the video surfaced, brought two coffees, and sat on the floor with me until I was ready to talk. She came back the next day, too.

And Seth Vance, my sweetheart since we were kids, came to campus when he heard about the video. He took my hand in front of a crowd outside the lecture hall and said it loud enough for everyone to hear.

“Whatever name she goes by, she’s still my fiancée.”