My Husband Stole My Mother's Heart for His First Love's Sister

Chapter 1

6,567 words

I was pregnant.

The test was in my handbag, wrapped in tissue, beside a small velvet box. Two lines. I had checked it three times in the clinic bathroom and once more in the car.

It was our fifth anniversary. Nico owned casinos, hotels, and half the docks in the city. He already had everything money could buy. The key in that velvet box was the only gift I believed he would truly keep.

“Donna,” The guard at the Rossi headquarters straightened as I stepped out of the elevator. The men in dark suits lowered their eyes as I passed. Five years, and they still treated me like I was the Don himself.

I smiled at every one of them.

Nico’s office was at the end of the hall. The door was open a few inches. I raised my hand to knock, then I heard Marco Bellini. His consigliere.

“The doctor is back, Nico.”

My hand stopped in the air.

“Which doctor?” Nico’s voice was flat. It was the voice he used for business.

“Dr. Alden. The one from the private hospital, five years ago. He left the country after the operation. Now he’s resurfaced, and he kept copies of everything.”

“Then buy them. Or bury him.”

“He’s asking about Evelyn’s mother.”

I stopped breathing. My mother died five years ago. Complications after a car accident, Nico had told me, holding me while I sobbed into his shirt.

I should have left. I stayed.

“She could have survived,” Marco said quietly. “You know that. She was badly hurt, but she still had a chance.”

“Giulia didn’t have time,” Nico said.

Giulia. Valentina’s little sister. The girl who needed a new heart that same week.

“The only match was in that hospital room,” Nico added. “I ordered the doctors to stop treating her and took her heart.”

Something inside me went very still. A heart. My mother’s heart.

Valentina Bianchi. I knew that name better than I wanted to. She's the woman Nico loved before he ever met me. She was also the woman Damian Ferraro chose over me.

When my mother was critically ill, I begged my fiancé, Damian Ferraro, for help, but he abandoned me and married Valentina Bianchi.

Desperate, I turned to Mafia Don Nico Rossi to save her, but the operation failed.

I had always believed Nico’s love for me was real, that he had long since moved on from her.

I had been wrong about everything.

“Do you regret it?” Marco asked.

“No.”

One word, and it hit harder than any slap.

“Her mother was already in a hospital bed, Marco. Giulia was young. Valentina would have fallen apart if she lost her sister. I couldn’t watch that.”

My hand found the key in my bag. It opened a small house on the east side of the city, where Nico spent his happiest childhood years with his mother. After she died, a family fight cost him the house. He never stopped mourning her. He still kept her rosary in his desk drawer. So I bought the house back in secret. For months I restored it, using his old family photos spread across my kitchen table. I repainted the porch the exact shade of green from one faded picture. Tonight I was going to place the key in his palm and watch his face.

He grieved his own mother for twenty years. He killed mine.

“But what if Evelyn finds out?” Marco asked.

“She won’t. Tha's why I married her to repay a debt, and to keep her from digging,” Nico said. “She’s had five years of luxury, affection, the Rossi name. I was good to her. That covers it.”

Five years of him kissing my temple before meetings. Of him driving through a storm at two in the morning to bring me soup when I had the flu. Of him saying he couldn’t sleep unless I was beside him. All of it, payment on a debt.

“And Valentina?” Marco asked.

“Valentina is the only woman I have ever loved.”

I pressed my palm over my mouth.

“Nico, if the doctor reaches her first—”

“Then he doesn’t reach her.” His voice was flat, almost bored. “And if Evelyn finds out and tries to fight me, or goes after Valentina, I’ll have her silenced. Permanently. I would hate to. But I will.”

My free hand dropped to my stomach.

The baby. Barely a few weeks along. Nobody knew. Not even him. If he could say that about me, what would he do to a child with my blood in it?

I stepped back. One step. Another. The carpet swallowed my footsteps. I walked past the guards with my chin level and my smile fixed in place. One of them said, “Happy anniversary, Donna,” I nodded.

I didn’t cry in the elevator. I didn’t cry in the lobby, or in the parking garage.

I cried when I shut the car door.

It came out of me like something torn loose. I gripped the steering wheel, the velvet box in my lap, and shook until I couldn’t see. I had planned for tonight. A candlelit dinner, the key, the test. I had practiced how I would say, “We’re going to have a baby.”

I opened the box. I thought of the wallpaper, the photographs, the months of work, everything I had put into it for him.

I wouldn’t give it to him now. I couldn’t make myself throw it away either. I closed my fist around it and put it back in my bag.

Then the tears came, and the lane lines blurred. I wiped my face with my sleeve. The next thing I knew, headlights filled the windshield. A horn. Metal screaming. Glass.

Then nothing.

…

I woke to a white ceiling and a steady beeping. My ribs ached. A warm hand was wrapped around mine.

Nico.

He sat beside the bed in a wrinkled shirt, no tie, and his eyes red. He looked like he hadn’t slept in days. He kissed my knuckles, then my forehead. His lips were shaking.

“Thank God,” he whispered. “Evelyn. Thank God!”

“What happened?” My voice came out rough.

“You crashed. They called me, and I thought—” He stopped. His jaw tightened. “I thought I lost you. I have never been so afraid in my life. Don’t ever do that to me again.”

If I hadn’t heard him with my own ears, I would have believed every word. His thumb brushed my cheek the way it always did. His eyes were wet. Maybe the fear was real. That was the cruelest part. Only hours ago, he had calmly discussed killing me.

Under the blanket, my hand slid down and rested low on my stomach. Still there. Still safe.

I made myself smile.

“I’m fine,” I said. “I was tired. I shouldn’t have been driving.”

“No more driving alone.”

“Okay.”

“I’m staying right here.”

“I know you will.”

He pressed his forehead to mine. I closed my eyes and let him hold me.

Nico believed me. He always had. He trusted me completely. That was his mistake.

Because while he whispered that he loved me, I made my decision. I would gather every piece of evidence. I would protect my child. I would get out from under his control.

And I would make him pay for my mother.