I Went Out for Our Anniversary Cake. I Came Back with Evidence
Chapter 2
I went home without the cake. At the kitchen counter, I opened the Instagram profile Mia had sent me.
Winifred Taylor had posted pictures of everything. The flowers on her desk. The view from the executive floor. A cup of bubble tea from a shop in Chinatown.
That one was from two months ago.
My amazing boss remembered my favorite order. How sweet is he?
In the photo, she was holding the half-empty cup up to Asher’s mouth. He was leaning in to drink from her straw, smiling at her over the lid. I could see his wedding ring where his hand rested on the table.
Asher hated sweet drinks. Whenever I asked him to stop for dessert with me, he said I could order whatever I wanted and he’d wait in the car. After a while, I stopped asking.
Apparently, Winifred had only had to hold out the straw.
I laughed once and kept scrolling.
A month ago, she’d posted a picture of an open lunch box.
He made this himself. Is there anything this man can’t do?
There were little sushi rolls, sliced pears, and strips of Wagyu I’d trimmed myself. I recognized the blue container and the crooked little divider that never snapped into place.
Asher used to lie awake with stomach pain after grabbing takeout between meetings. I’d taught myself to cook for him. Every morning I packed him something different, and every evening the container came home empty. Sometimes I’d ask how he’d liked it. He always said it was good.
I wondered if he’d ever opened the lid.
In the next photo, Winifred flashed a peace sign over the rim of a wineglass.
I messed up a project today and thought I was done for. He brought me here to cheer me up. Said I’m still the best.
I recognized the brass railing behind her. The Summit. She was sitting in the curved booth by the window, the one Asher and I always asked for.
Years ago, after a fight with my father, I’d walked out of the family home and taken a waitressing job there under my mother’s maiden name. I wanted to see how long I could get by without somebody hearing my last name and calling him.
One night, a drunk in a corner booth slid his hand up my skirt when I leaned over to clear his plate. Asher was across the room. He was on his feet before I could get the man’s hand off me. He knocked him to the floor, and when the man came up swinging a bottle at my head, Asher pulled me against him and took the blow himself.
I still remembered pressing a clean bar towel to his scalp with both hands. He kept asking if the man had hurt me. I kept telling him to hold still.
Back then, Asher had no money and no crew. He didn’t even know my real last name. By the time I told him, I was already in love with him.
Now he’d taken Winifred to the Summit to make her feel better about a bad day at work. I stared at the empty seat beside her and knew exactly where he’d been sitting.
The newest post was from yesterday.
Two days until the Southgate bid meeting. He says this project is my big debut. Best gift ever.
I read it twice.
My father had spent the last years of his life laying the groundwork for the Southgate waterfront redevelopment. He’d brought men to the same table who usually sent lawyers just to avoid shaking hands. Toward the end, he started taking me to those meetings. He’d planned to hand the project over to me on my twenty-eighth birthday.
He died before he could. I’d spent months finishing the plans. Last night, just after midnight, I’d sent Asher my presentation because he’d asked to see the latest version. And here was Winifred announcing to everyone that he’d promised her Southgate before I’d even sent him the deck.
Late that afternoon, I heard the front door open.
I turned my phone facedown as Asher came into the kitchen. He walked straight over, wrapped his arms around me, and rested his chin on my head.
“Hey, babe,” he murmured. “I missed you.”
His jacket smelled like gardenias. I’d caught that same heavy sweetness when Winifred stepped out of his office that morning. It was stronger now, caught in the wool at his shoulder. I held my breath and waited for him to let go.
He took my hand and gave it a little swing.
“There’s a dinner at the tower tonight. The executives and a few people who do business with the family.” He smiled down at me. “Come with me. We can have our anniversary dinner another night.”
So much for making it home for dinner. He’d had all morning to tell me about the banquet. Now he wanted me to smile for a room full of people who’d already heard what happened upstairs.
He picked up my coat and held it open for me. I slipped my arms into it before he could ask why I was still staring at him. I wanted to see how he’d introduce me.
By the time we reached the banquet hall at Sanchez Tower, the chandeliers were lit and the champagne was out. Asher walked in holding my hand. An older man from the docks lifted his glass to me. I knew him from my father’s table. A woman beside him leaned over to ask who I was. All the way across the room, conversations broke off as people turned toward us.
Winifred came straight through the crowd in a white cocktail dress. Her eyes were red at the edges. She stopped in front of me and lowered her head.
“Mrs. Sanchez, I’m so sorry. I should’ve known better than to accept a ride from Mr. Sanchez. It won’t happen again.” She clasped her hands in front of her. “Please don’t be angry with me.”
She spoke just loudly enough for the nearest tables to hear. A woman gave her a sympathetic smile. Someone else watched me over the rim of a champagne flute.
Then Winifred lifted her head, and the pendant at her throat caught the light.
A tiny gold crescent moon.
The pendant turned on its chain. The letter engraved on the back caught the light.
P.
My mother had fastened that necklace around my neck herself. I’d worn it almost every day until the chain broke. Asher had taken it out of my palm and promised to have the best jeweler in Manhattan fix it. My parents had been gone for years by then. He knew what it meant to me.
That had been almost a year ago. Every time I asked, he told me the jeweler needed a little longer. I’d believed him. I’d even been grateful he was taking such care with it.
The chain looked perfect now.
He’d taken it out of my hand and put it around hers.
My stomach lurched. Asher’s hand was still around mine, and Winifred was waiting for me to tell her she was forgiven. I locked my knees and fixed my eyes on that little gold moon until I knew I could stay on my feet.