A night with the wrong twins

Seven years ago, nineteen-year-old Jennifer Morrison was pulled from the freezing Chicago River by a stranger named William, who vanished into the night. All she kept was his face and the memory of a dark mark on his shoulder. Obsessed with finding him, Jennifer searches for seven years.

At a Gates Holdings charity gala, she meets Wilson Gates, the identical twin of William. Believing he is her savior, she pours out her gratitude. Wilson, who knows his brother has searched for her too, stays silent, craving the feeling of being chosen. They spend the night together.